NZ Federation of Freshwater Anglers

Home Fishing Articles
Fishing Articles
Sawyer's Pheasant Tail and Variants
Written by Tony Orman   
Wednesday, 24 June 2009 11:42

Frank Sawyer's Pheasant Tail nymph is a wonderful nymph pattern. It has worked so well for anglers all around the world. Frank Sawyer, a river keeper on an English chalk stream, developed the pattern and wrote about it in his wonderful book "Nymphs and The Trout". The book is a classic and a must for the dedicated fly fisher.

 

        The Pheasant Tail tied from simply cock pheasant herl and copper wire, probably imitates the deleatidium mayfly so common in many New Zealand trout streams. You can make variations, called variants, on Sawyer's original pattern, by varying the thorax or even tying in a brief hackle to give added "life."
        One variant I  have much faith in, is the Speckled Nymph.Many years ago on the Mohaka River I was skunked for a start. I tried another favourite the Stonefly Nymph, an olive seal fur-based pattern on an 8 or 10 hook, that imitates the large green stone-fly that inhabits more bouldery rivers. However that particular morning the stonefly failed. I found the trout not only would not take it but even showed mild panic after inspecting it. I was puzzled by this uncharacteristic behaviour. I tried for several other brown trout which were feeding and I put each one down, although my presentation appeared satisfactory.
 
        I had tried other nymphs such as a coch-y-bondhu styled nymph on a long shank hook with a peacock herl body and very sparse hackle. Following that came  the Kiwi creation of the hare and copper, the gold ribbed hares ear and yes Sawyer's pheasant tail to name a few of several.
        Then I tied on a speckled nymph, which is basically a variation on a pheasant tail with a turquoise-green thorax.
       Suddenly I found that elusive success. I landed three good browns.
        So little details do count to the trout!
 
        One might suppose wilderness brown trout might not be too selective but the reality is that trout, anywhere and anytime, can be very selective to the point of discerning small differences of variation in a pattern.
  Remember the trout had refused the pheasant tail but took a variation on the pheasant tail theme.
 
        The Pheasant Tail nymph, of course,  is a brilliantly simple creation.
        In New Zealand the pheasant tail nymph imitates the mayfly species of Deleatidium which hatches in New Zealand's summer months of December, January, February and early March. However the pheasant tail nymph does bear a resemblance to other mayfly nymphs and is also regarded in New Zealand as a good general pattern too.
        While Frank Sawyer tied his pheasant tail from just herl and copper wire and with no thread, I, far less skilled, use tying thread rather than make the gold wire serve double duty. I doubt if Frank Sawyer would have objected.
        I prefer a dark red (auburn) copper wire although it seems Frank Sawyer used a copper wire tending gold. I'm not sure the trout notice either way on this point.
       
        Smith's nymph (A dear friend the late Squadron leader A G Smith of Nelson, a very fine fly fisher) , is a pheasant tail variant is tied as Sawyer's pheasant tail except that a thorax of coarse medium blue-grey wool and a hackle of two turns of Rhode Island red hen are incorporated. The tail, body (ribbed with copper wire) and wing case are essentially as for the original pheasant tail.
        Smithy found this pheasant tail variant on a size 8 to 16 hook, fishes well to the brown trout of the Nelson region. Like Smithy I have often found the speckled nymph, also a pheasant tail variant, to be the successful pattern for the day.
 
        The speckled nymph pattern, which probably imitates  the Oniscgaster distans species of mayfly, is:-
Hook; 6 to 10
Tail: Orange and black breast feathers of cock pheasant (long)
Body: grey cock pheasant tail ribbed with dark copper wire
Thorax: Greenstone shade wool
Wing case: cock pheasant tail rather dark
Hackle: Very sparse, Greenwell's (ginger and black). The fibres reach the bend of the hook.
        In my tyings I substitute for Jim's tail, golden pheasant tippets.
        But don't ignore the original pheasant tail either.
        One trip into a wilderness river, we couldn't get the trout to take any nymphs until we went down to tiny size 16 pheasant tails.
 
        I gave Frank Sawyer and his pheasant tail, a quiet murmur of thanks, whether for that size 16 pheasant tail or the variants.
 
Kahawai - Top Sport!
Written by Tony Orman   
Wednesday, 24 June 2009 09:40
In recent years I've been more and more irresistibly pulled to fishing for kahawai with the fly rod. The reason is two fold-first the fly is so much more effective and secondly, it's just so much fun.
        With regards to the latter, a kahawai on a fly rod makes a trout look like a sloth.
So much so, that I could quite easily give up trout fishing - given the declining quality and quantity of trout I've observed over the last 10 or 20 years- and just go kahawai fishing with my fly rod.
        Of course Fish and Game won't like that comparison! Fish and Game is in the business of selling trout licences and publicising trout numbers are down, would hardly do sales any good. But then aren't they meant to be managers of the trout fishery? Or is it that Fish and Game like some "businesses" can fall into the trap of  believing its own spin?
        I digress. Back to kahawai.
        Fly gear for kahawai doesn't have to be fancy. I've used a very average aluminium construction fly reel loaded with a fair amount of backing and a weight 7 double tapered floating fly line, to which is a strong nylon trace, not tapered but level - just a length of 6 kg nylon off a saltwater nylon spool. The rod is a bit of an old "dunger". Good friend John Morton top fly caster, reckons it's a a "dog" so you can understand when I say it doesn't cast that long or good a line.
        Saltwater flies - you can buy them in the shops for just under $5 each or you can make your own. Tying them is fun.
        River mouths are best for kahawai. But they can change greatly from month to month depending on the dominant wind direction, weather and sea. A river mouth with a narrow neck where on a falling tide the river mouth issues from, is the ideal type.
        I like a falling tide, about two hours after full tide.
        I like to wear polaroids to spot fish if I can. You often will see grey shape come at the fly, swirl and take or turn away. If it does the latter, I reason I haven't quite got the right fly. Kahawaiu are not always a push over. They can selectively feed, focusing sometimes on tiny bait fish so only a small slim fly will do the trick.
        Don't try to hold the reel handle when you hook a kahawai. You will only get whacked knuckles. Instead palm the reel, holding the palm of the hand on the underside of the reel.
        I keep the rod on the horizontal so as to be inconspicuous. There's nothing like a vertically held, bent rod to make some anglers gallop in your direction!
        Kahawai are great smoked and okay to eat fresh, if straight away. It's certainly better than paying $33 a kg for snapper of $26 for blue cod - a shocking state of affairs and an indictment of a ministry that doesn't know a fish tail from the fish heads they employ!
        Sometimes I have two or three kahawai at once, pursuing the fly. It's exciting stuff!
        Fly fishing, 90% of the time, is so much more successful than the conventional spinning methods. By my mickey-mouse observations, I've worked out often on the fly rod I have a 700 percent better catch rate than the "surfcasters" and spin anglers..
        Fly fishing for kahawai does depend on the fish being within reach of the fly rod. On days when they're not or the river mouth doesn't suit the fly rod, then the spin angler will beat the fly fisher. For that reason the best river mouths are those with a narrow neck through which the river flows to join the saltwater.
 


NZ Federation of Freshwater Anglers Template by Ahadesign Powered by Joomla! feed-image Feed Entries